Hot Pies Pizzeria

Enjoy delicious, budget-friendly pizza, wings, hoagies, and more at Hot Pies Pizzeria in New Milford, PA. Perfect crust, cheesy breadsticks, and flavorful dips await — call +1 570-465-7437!

Welcome to Hot Pies Pizzeria

Experience the finest dining

Hot Pies Pizzeria
Hot Pies Pizzeria
Hot Pies Pizzeria
Hot Pies Pizzeria

Located at 253 Jackson St in New Milford, Hot Pies Pizzeria stands as a beloved spot for pizza enthusiasts. The aroma of fresh-baked crust greets you at the door, adding an irresistible allure. Diners appreciate the variety on the menu, from classic pizzas to wings and loaded cheesesteaks. Whether it’s a cozy dinner for one or a gathering with friends, the options satisfy every craving. Named for its delightful hot pies, this pizzeria captures the heart of the community, making it a go-to destination for locals. Friendly service complements the vibrant atmosphere, making each visit feel special. Dive into a slice, and discover why Hot Pies is the talk of New Milford.

Hot Pies Pizzeria offers an extensive menu that keeps diners coming back for more. The highlight is the pizza, available in various sizes, including 18" rounds, half sheets, and full sheets. The specialty pizzas, like ‘The Boss Man’ half sheet, showcase bold flavors and generous toppings. Beyond pizza, patrons enjoy crispy wings, savory cheesesteaks, and hearty burgers, all reasonably priced.

For those looking to snack, the cheesy breadsticks and dips add an extra layer of indulgence. Each dish comes with the promise of quality, and every bite reflects the restaurant's commitment to flavor and satisfaction. The bustling atmosphere, especially on Fridays, brings energy, while the welcoming staff ensure everyone feels at home.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

253 Jackson St, New Milford, PA 18834, United States

Phone

+1 570-465-7437

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Hot Pies Pizzeria
Hot Pies Pizzeria
Hot Pies Pizzeria
Hot Pies Pizzeria

Established as a local favorite, Hot Pies Pizzeria combines affordability and deliciousness. Located conveniently in New Milford, it captures the essence of community dining. The menu features something for everyone. Families flock here for the shareable pizzas, while solo diners often indulge in inventive pasta bowls or comforting sandwiches. The pizzas shine, with the crust often praised for its perfect blend of crispy and chewy. Specialty pizzas often sell out, so it's wise to arrive early or order ahead on busy nights.

It’s not just about the food; it’s about the experience. Gather with friends to enjoy Friday night specials or bring the kids for casual dining that feels like a treat. The commitment to customer service is evident, making it a unique spot where everyone knows your name. The openings for lunch during the week offer a chance for an affordable bite without the weekend rush, allowing guests to savor the flavors without the crowd. Hot Pies embraces its local heritage by participating in community events, making it a cornerstone of the New Milford dining scene. Stop by for the flavors, stay for the friendships.

Hot Pies Pizzeria

Hot Pies Pizzeria features a casual yet inviting exterior on Jackson Street, making it easy to spot as you stroll through New Milford. The bright signage invites passersby to grab a bite, while outdoor seating offers a relaxed dining experience in pleasant weather. It’s not uncommon to see locals enjoying slices on the patio during the summer. The overall vibe is laid-back and friendly, perfect for families, friends, and date nights. Hot Pies Pizzeria creates a warm atmosphere that welcomes everyone, embodying the spirit of community.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-8 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-8 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-8 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Decent crust and sauce. Variety of offerings in their ready-made pizza slice case. Worth the stop for a quick bite. I had the bacon and ham. My son had the plain/cheese. Friendly staff. Thanks!

D
David B.

Called a placed an order. I was coming from 1/2 hour away and female on phone was so nice and gave me directions. Got there and picked up our pizza and wings. We had never been there before. The pizza looked great and could t wait til we got home to have a piece.....had one in the car. It was the best pizza I've had lately. Got home and had a couple wings. PHENOMINAL. Definitely will go back and may be a weekly dinner . So glad we found it .

J
Jennifer D.

I'm absolutely in love with their square pizza which is huge for me because I'm not a fan at all of square pizza and I actually want it like all the time. Their cheesy breadsticks are amazing, wings always cooked to perfection, steak and cheese is to die for. Only request, please sell mozzarella sticks otherwise, 110% reccomend trying! Their round is also delicious, super big slices and worth every penny.

K
Koya

1st time there wish we didn't wait as long to try it. Round pizza was great, asked for crispy wings they were spot on, garlic fries were delicious, knots had nice crisp and fluffy inside and my daughter said the spaghetti and meatballs was really good. Definitely recommending to friends and family.

B
Bill J.

Just passing through new Milford and saw this place, friendly staff, pizza was great!

J
Josh B.

Great food. Staff is great. Take out only... so no real atmosphere. Have to be careful pulling in and out, big dip transitioning from road to parking lot

G
Gina K.